Hurt.

[wmarskell]

saw Mar 26th, 2006, Winnipeg MB set list and I saw the song HURT.

Is matt playing some johnny cash, or is this another new song???

[HouseOfSmokeAndMirrors]

its actually a NIN song that mr.cash covered, can't say i care for matt's version unfortunitely i've been tortured with that song though :angry: ;)

[stephen]

How can you not like that song, Cash's cover was way better then NIN.

[glo]

Cash's cover was better than NIN's but Matty's version doesn't top Cash's

 

#1 Cash

#2 Matt

#3 NIN

Edited March 27, 2006 by glo

[Vance]

It would be cool to here him (Matt) sing it but I go to a Matt Good show to here Matt Good sing Matt Good songs. I'd rather him take that song out and sing Life Beyond the Minimum safe Distance or another rare song.

[uglyredhonda]

85% of the people who think Cash's version is the best didn't know it was a Nine Inch Nails song the first time they heard it.

[mrchipps]

Yeah I was going to say wasn't "hurt" originally written by NIN?

[saturnine]

no one's version of hurt is better than nin. come on, people.

[Vance]

it's true.

[Guest apsham]

WHAT WHAT WHAT!? Does anyone have this on the hub?

[Jarrod]

the original version is the best version.

 

it goes like this:

 

1. NIN

2.Cash

3. Matt.

[wmarskell]

sorry i am an idiot for writing it was a cash song. i just assumed matts cover would be cashes cover. being that he is a cash fan.

weird choice for him.

[andielicious]

I would have to say:

 

1. Cash

2. NIN

3. Matt

 

I did enjoy Matt's version, and would probably choose to listen to Matt's version over the others, strictly because I am more of a Matt fan than anything else and I adore his voice. But you cannot deny that the NIN version and Johnny Cash's version are superior.

 

I downloaded the Matt version done live today, but I can't for the life of me remember where I downloaded it from. I was at work when I downloaded it. My brain was fried by that point.

[Prometheon]

I dunno. The Matt version may be better than the Cash one. It's more dynamic.

 

You can't really either to the NIN one though. They're so different.

[Crusader]

We've added an audio rip from one of the videos. Working on finding a full clip. Video may also be up on the site in the next few days.

[Prometheon]

Just bought it. Sounds pretty damn good, thanks Anton.

[5ilent Narcotic]

no one's version of hurt is better than nin. come on, people.

Sometimes I think you're the only one who thinks on here.

[Crusader]

So said the two NIN fans lol. NIN is quality but I still like Cash's, mainly because he released it at the right time (before he died).

[CaptainRocket]

Cash's version is better, but only slightly. The original is still really fucking good, especially with that sweet ending.

 

And if we want to get technical, Matt is playing the Cash "crown of thorns" version, so technically it is a Cash cover...whatever.

Edited March 28, 2006 by CaptainRocket

[NME]

NIN version is far better. Trent can sell that song better than anyone.

[prototypepariah]

it's NIN version of Apparitions...All three are good?

[Shiri]

I like the original the best.

[destined4failure]

Reznor wrote it because that dude's full of angst anyway. Cash sold it with his version on pure emotion, singing it as a retrospect on his life.

[Peter Griffin]

Matt's version is too whiny.

[glo]

I think it's (matt's) is starting to grow on me