Jump to content
rebellious_L

2009 Matthew Good (band) Elimination

Recommended Posts

Posted

Round 1 D Results!

 

1) Black Helicopter vs. Black Helicopter (Massey Hall) vs. Black Helicopter (acoustic) 17-35-11* (really disappointed by the lack of love for the acoustic version)

2) Everything is Automatic vs. The Fall of Man 10-12 (a bit surprised from that one)

3) Strangest One of All vs. We're So Heavy 4-18

4) Single Explosion vs. She's In It For the Money 18-4

5) Bad Pennies vs. Alabama Motel Room 6-15*

6) Breath of a Nation vs. I Miss New Wave 2-20

7) Anti-Pop vs. Native Son 16-6

8) I, The Throw Away vs. 21st Century Living 6-16

9) Truffle Pigs vs. Truffle Pigs (rooms) 17-5

 

*denotes abstention

 

Round 1 E

 

1) Generation X-Wing vs. Generation X-Wing (rooms)

- Generation X-Wing (rooms) won this matchup in round 1 in 2005

- Generation X-Wing (rooms) lost in round 2 to Man of Action in 2005

- MY VOTE - i guess I gotta vote for at least one rooms song, so Generation X-Wing (rooms)

 

2) In a World Called Catastrophe vs. Man of Action

- Catastrophe lost in round 2 to Jenni's Song in 2005

- Man of Action lost to Avalanche in round 3 in 2005

- MY VOTE - Man of Action

 

3) Deep Six vs. The Vancouver National Anthem

- Deep Six lost in round 1 to While We Were Hunting Rabbits in 2005

- The Vancouver National Anthem did not exist in 2005

- MY VOTE - VNA

 

4) The Boy Come Home vs. The Future Is Rated

- The Boy Come Home did not exist in 2005

- The Future Is Rated lost in round 3 to Primetime Deliverance in 2005

- MY VOTE - The Boy Come Home

 

5) Running For Home vs. My Life As a Circus Clown

- Running For Home finished 13th overall in 2005, lost in round 4 to Primetime Deliverance

- Circus Clown lost to Look Happy, It's the End of the World in round 1 in 2005

- MY VOTE - Running For Home

 

6) Radio Bomb vs. The Devil's In Your Details

- Radio Bomb lost in round 1 to Put Out Your Lights in 2005

- Details did not exist in 2005

- MY VOTE - Radio Bomb

 

7) Giant vs. The Boy Who Could Explode

- Giant lost to The Workers Sing a Song of Mass Production in round 3 in 2005

- Boy Who Could Explode did not exist in 2005

- MY VOTE - Giant

 

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure vs. 99% Of Us Is Failure (live acoustic - iTunes)

- Neither song existed in 2005

- MY VOTE - album version

 

9) Haven't Slept in Years (LOTGA) vs. Haven't Slept In Years (Raygun)

- Raygun version won in round 1 in 2005

- lost to Sort of a Protest Song in round 2

- MY VOTE - Raygun

 

voting for this round open until Wednesday at noon.

Join or sign in to the forums to disable this ad!

Posted (edited)

1) Generation X-Wing

 

2) Man of Action

 

3) Deep Six

 

4) The Boy Come Home

 

5) Running For Home

 

6) Radio Bomb

 

7) The Boy Who Could Explode

 

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure (album)

 

9) Haven't Slept In Years (Raygun)

Edited by Moonlight_Graham
Posted

1) Generation X-Wing

2) Man of Action

3) Deep Six

4) The Boy Come Home

5) Running For Home

6) Devils in your Details

7) Giant

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure (album)

9) Haven't Slept In Years (Raygun)

Posted

1) Generation X-Wing

 

2) Man of Action

 

3) The Vancouver National Anthem

 

4) The Boy Come Home

 

5) Running For Home

 

6) Radio Bomb

 

7) The Boy Who Could Explode

 

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure

 

9) Haven't Slept in Years (LOTGA)

Posted

1) Generation X-Wing

2) Man of Action

3) The Vancouver National Anthem

4) The Future Is Rated

5) Running For Home

6) The Devil's In Your Details

7) Giant

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure

9) Haven't Slept In Years (Raygun)

Posted

1. Rooms Version

2. Man of Action (actually never been that big of a fan of it, but not a big fan of Catastophe either)

3. Vancouver National Anthem (hard choice)

4. Future is X-Rated

5. Running for Home

6. Devil's in Your Details

7. Giant

8. Album Version

9. LOTGA version (easily)

Posted (edited)

1) Generation X-Wing (rooms)

2) Man of Action

3) The Vancouver National Anthem

4) The Future Is X-Rated

5) Running For Home

6) Radio Bomb

7) Giant

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure (album)

9) Haven't Slept In Years (LOTGA)

Edited by johnerwin
Posted

1) Generation X-Wing

2) Man of Action

3) The Vancouver National Anthem

4) The Boy Come Home

5) Running For Home

6) The Devil's In Your Details

7) Giant

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure

9) Haven't Slept In Years (Raygun)

Posted

1. Generation X-Wing (Rooms)

2. Man of Action

3. The Vancouver National Anthem

4. The Future Is X-Rated

5. My Life As A Circus Clown

6. The Devil's In Your Details

7. Giant

8. 99% Of Us Is Failure

9. Haven't Slept In Years (LOTGA)

Posted

Generation X-Wing

Man of Action

The Vancouver National Anthem

The Future is X-Rated

Running for Home

Radio Bomb

Fuck you for this matchup, I decided "The Boy Who Could Explode" by coin toss

99& of Us is Failure

Haven't Slept in Years (LOTGA, due to vocals being better)

Posted

1. Rooms Version

2. Man of Action

3. Vancouver National Anthem

4. The Boy Come Home

5. My Life as a Circus Clown

6. Radio Bomb

7. Giant

8. Album Version

9. LOTGA version

Posted

1) Generation X-Wing (Rooms)

 

2) In A World Called Catastrophe

 

3) VNA

 

4) The Boy Come Home

 

5) Running For Home

 

6) Radio Bomb

 

7) Giant

 

8) Album Version

 

9) Raygun Version

Posted

1) Generation X-Wing

2) Man of Action

3) Vancouver National Anthem

4) The Boy Come Home

5) Running For Home

6) Devil's in your Details

7) Giant

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure - album

9) Haven't Slept In Years - Raygun

Posted

Rooms

In a World Called Catastrophe

The Vancouver National Anthem

The Boy Come Home

Running For Home

Radio Bomb

Giant

99%

(Raygun)

Posted

1) Generation X-Wing

 

2) Man of Action

 

3) The Vancouver National Anthem

 

4) The Future Is X Rated

 

5) Running For Home

 

6) Radio Bomb

 

7) Giant

 

8) 99% Of Us Is Failure

 

9) Haven't Slept In Years (Raygun)

Posted

1. Rooms

2. Man of Action

3. Vancouver National Anthem

4. Future is X-Rated

5. Running for Home

6. Devil's in your Details

7. Giant

8. Album

9. Raygun

Posted

Generation X-Wing (Rooms)

Man of Action (really tough call)

The Vancouver National Anthem

The Future Is X-Rated

Running For Home

The Devil's In Your Details

Giant

99% Of Us Is Failure

Haven't Slept in Years (Raygun)

Posted

1. rooms

2. man of action

3. vancouver national anthem

4. future is x rated

5. running for home

6. radio bomb!

7. giant

8.album

9. raygun version

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.