Jump to content
rebellious_L

2009 Matthew Good (band) Elimination

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Round 1 C Results!

 

1) Last Parade vs. Buffalo Seven 21-4

2) Sort of a Protest Song vs. Under the Influence 21-4

3) While We Were Hunting Rabbits vs. All Together 20-5

4) Oh Be Joyful vs. Going All The Way 7-18

5) Little Terror vs. Volcanoes 9-16

6) Empty Road vs. So Long Mrs. Smith 23-2

7) Load Me Up vs. Middle Class Gangsters 19-6

8) Great Whales of the Sea vs. Moon Over Marin 22-3

9) A Silent Army In The Trees vs. A Silent Army In The Trees (live acoustic) 22-3

 

Massey Hall Bonus Round winners were Champions of Nothing and Avalanche, so they will be added to the competition. Also, Black Helicopter and Apparitions from Massey Hall will be added since they were requested and I can easily add them in, and I'll explain more about that in a minute.

 

Round 1 D

 

1) Black Helicopter vs. Black Helicopter (live acoustic - iTunes bonus track) vs. Black Helicopter (live - Massey Hall)

!!!!special instructions!!!! - rank each song 1,2, and 3, in order of preference (1 being best), 2 points for a first place vote, and 1 point for a second place vote. The top song from these three will go on, the other two will be eliminated.

- none of these songs existed in 2005

- MY VOTE - torn between the two live versions, but I'll go with 1) live acoustic, 2) Massey Hall, and 3) album version

 

2) Everything is Automatic vs. The Fall of Man

- Everything is Automatic finished in 16th place overall in 2005

- The Fall of Man lost to Strange Days in round 2 in 2005

- MY VOTE - The Fall of Man

 

3) Strangest One of All vs. We're So Heavy

- Strangest One of All lost to Flashdance II in round 1 in 2005

- We're So Heavy lost in round 1 to 21st Century Living in 2005

- MY VOTE - We're So Heavy

 

4) Single Explosion vs. She's In It For the Money

- neither song existed in 2005

- MY VOTE - Single Explosion

 

5) Bad Pennies vs. Alabama Motel Room

- Bad Pennies did not exist in 2005

- Alabama Motel Room lost to House of Smoke and Mirrors in round 1 in 2005

- MY VOTE - Bad Pennies

 

6) Breath of a Nation vs. I Miss New Wave

- Breath of a Nation was not involved in 2005

- I Miss New Wave lost to Primetime Deliverance in round 2 in 2005

- MY VOTE - I Miss New Wave

 

7) Anti-Pop vs. Native Son

- Anti-Pop lost to While We Were Hunting Rabbits in round 3 in 2005

- Native Son lost to It's Been Awhile Since I've Been Your Man in round 2 in 2005

- MY VOTE - Anti-Pop

 

8) I, The Throw Away vs. 21st Century Living

- I, The Throw Away lost to Load Me Up in round 1 in 2005

- 21st Century Living lost to Everything is Automatic in round 3 in 2005

- MY VOTE - 21st Century Living

 

9) Truffle Pigs vs. Truffle Pigs (rooms)

- Truffle Pigs beat Truffle Pigs (rooms) in round 1 in 2005

- Truffle Pigs lost in round 3 to Weapon

- MY VOTE - Truffle Pigs

 

Voting for this round open until Saturday at midnight

Edited by rebellious_L
Posted

1) Massy Hall

Album

itunes

2) Everything is Automatic

3) We're so heavy

4) She's in it for the money

5) Alabama Motel Room

6) I miss new wave

7) Anti-pop

8) 21st Century Living - extremely close

9) Truffle Pigs (rooms) - extremely close

Posted (edited)

1. Black Helicopter (live - Massey Hall)

2. Black Helicopter (live acoustic - iTunes bonus track)

3. Black Helicopter (album)

 

2) The Fall of Man

3) We're So Heavy

4) Single Explosion

5) Alabama Motel Room

6) I Miss New Wave

7) Native Son

8) I, The Throw Away

9) Truffle Pigs (AOB version)

Edited by johnerwin
Posted

1) 1. Black Helicopter (live - Massey Hall) / 2. Black Helicopter / 3. Black Helicopter (i tunes)

2) The Fall of Man

3) We're So Heavy

4) Single Explosion

5) Alabama Motel Room

6) I Miss New Wave

7) Anti-Pop

8) I, The Throw Away

9) Truffle Pigs

Posted

1) 1st - Massey Hall, 2nd - Album

 

2) Everything is Automatic

 

3) We're So Heavy

 

4) She's In It For the Money

 

5) Alabama Motel Room

 

6) I Miss New Wave

 

7) Anti-Pop

 

8) 21st Century Living

 

9) Truffle Pigs

Posted

1) Massey-Album-Live Acoustic

2) The Fall of Man

3) We're So Heavy

4) A Single Explosion

5) Bad Pennies

6) I Miss New Wave

7) Anti-Pop

8) 21st Century Living

9)Truffle Pigs

Posted

1) 1 Massey 2 Album 3 Acoustic

2) The Fall of Man

3) We're So Heavy

4) Single Explosion

5) Bad Pennies

6) I Miss New Wave (close one, both great)

7) Anti-Pop

8) 21st Century Living

9) Truffle Pigs

Posted

Massey Hall

Studio

itunes

 

Automatic

We're So Heavy

Money

Alabama Motel Room

I Miss New Wave

Native Son

21st Century Living

Rooms

Posted

1) 1.Studio,2.Massey Hall,3.The other one

2) Everything Is Automatic

3) We're So Heavy

4) Single Explosion

5) Alabama Motel Room

6) I Miss New Wave

7) Anti-Pop

8) 21st Century Living

9) Truffle Pigs (studio)

Posted

1. Black Helicopter (live - Massey Hall), Black Helicopter (album), Black Helicopter (live acoustic - iTunes bonus track)

2. The Fall of Man

3. Strangest One of All

4. Single Explosion

5. Alabama Motel Room

6. Breath of a Nation

7. Anti-Pop

8. 21st Century Living

9. Truffle Pigs

Posted

1) 1. Massey Hall 2. Album 3. i tunes

2) The Fall of Man

3) We're So Heavy

4) Single Explosion

5) Alabama Motel Room

6) I Miss New Wave

7) Anti-Pop

8) 21st Century Living

9) Truffle Pigs

Posted

1. Acoustic | 2. Massey Hall | 3. Album Version

Automatic

We're so Heavy

Single Explosion

Alabama

New Wave

Native Son

21st Century Living

Album Version

Posted

How did Under The Influence lose, and so badly???

 

1. Acoustic 2. Live Massey 3. Album (album version sucks, the demo versionis even much better)

Fall of Man

Strangest One of All

Single Explosion

Alabama Motel Room

I Miss New Wave

Native Son

I, The Throw Away

Truffle Pigs

Posted

1. 1. Massey, 2. Album, 3. itunes

2. Everything is Automatic

3. We're So Heavy

4. A Single Explosion

5. Alabama Motel Room

6. I Miss New Wave

7. Anti-pop

8. 21st Century Living

9. Truffle Pigs

Posted

Black Helicopter:

1. Massey Hall

2. Hospital Music

3. Live acoustic

 

Everything is Automatic

We're So Heavy

A Single Explosion

Bad Pennies

I Miss New Wave

Anti-Pop

21st Century Living

Truffle Pigs

 

This is the first round I actually downloaded a couple songs just so I could decide. They would be Strangest One of All and Native Son. I have the albums but was too lazy to go get them.

Posted

1) i)Live ii)iTunes iii)Album

2) EiA

3) We're So Heavy

4) Single Explosion

5) Alabama

6) New Wave

7) Anti Pop

8) 21st Century Living

9) Rooms

Posted

1) Black Helicopter:

- Acoustic

- Massey Hall

- Hospital Music

 

2) The Fall of Man

 

3) We're So Heavy

 

4) Single Explosion (damn tough one)

 

5) Never heard Bad Pennies, so I'll abstain

 

6) I Miss New Wave

 

7) Anti-Pop

 

8) 21st Century Living

 

9) Truffle Pigs (rooms)

 

They're starting to get a bit difficult now I see...

Posted

1)

1.Black Helicopter

2. Live Acoustic

3. Live

 

2) The Fall of Man

 

3) Were So Heavy

 

4) She's In It For The Money (difficult choice!)

 

5) Alabama Motel Room

 

6) I Miss New Wave

 

7) Anti-Pop

 

8) I, The Throw Away

 

9) Truffle Pigs

Posted

1.

1. Live

2. Studio

3. Acoustic

2. Everything is Automatic

3. Strangest One of All

4. Single Explosion

5. Alabama Motel Room

6. I miss New Wave

7. Anti-Pop

8. 21st Century Living

9. Rooms

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.