Jump to content
rebellious_L

2009 Matthew Good (band) Elimination

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

As far as I know it's been awhile since this has been done, and since we now have two more albums to include I think it's time we do it again. Format is the same, song vs. song, with the opportunity to bring back some songs later on that may get eliminated earlier than they deserve because of unfavorable matchups. Most matchups are random, the exception being tracks that are different versions of the same song, i.e. "Rooms." There are 144 songs to choose from as I threw in a few pre LOTGA tracks to bring the number to 144.

 

Round 1 A

 

1) Tripoli vs. Tripoli (rooms)

- Tripoli lost to Tripoli (rooms) in round 1 in 2005

- Tripoli (rooms) finished 9th overall

- MY VOTE - Tripoli

 

2) On Nights Like Tonight vs. Look Happy, It's the End of the World

- On Nights Like Tonight did not exist in 2005

- Look Happy, It's the End of the World lost to Weapon in round 2 in 2005

- MY VOTE - On Nights Like Tonight

 

3) Weapon vs. Failing the Rorschach Test

- Weapon finished 7th in 2005

- Failing the Rorschach Test lost to The Rat Who Would Be King in round 1 in 2005

- MY VOTE - Weapon

 

4) Born Losers vs. Raygun

- Born Losers didn't exist in 2005

- Raygun lost to Lullaby For a New World Order in round 1 in 2005

- MY VOTE - Born Losers

 

5) Hopeless vs. The War is Over

- Rematch from 2005

- The War is Over was victorious, but lost in round 2 to Under The Influence

- MY VOTE - Hopeless

 

6) Girl Wedged Under the Front of a Firebird vs. I Am Not Safer Than a Bank

- both tracks did not exist in 2005

- MY VOTE - I Am Not Safer Than a Bank

 

7) Big City Life vs. Jenni's Song

- Big City Life lost to While We Were Hunting Rabbits in round 2 in 2005

- Jenni's Song lost to Sort of a Protest Song in round 3 in 2005

- MY VOTE - Jenni's Song

 

8) My Out of Style is Coming Back vs. Metal Airplanes

- My Out of Style is Coming Back lost to Truffle Pigs in round 2 in 2005

- Metal Airplanes did not exist in 2005

- MY VOTE - Out of Style

 

9) Comfortable Criminals vs. Flashdance II

- Comfortable Criminals lost to Everything is Automatic in round 2 in 2005

- Flashdance II lost to Strange Days in round 3 in 2005

- MY VOTE - Flashdance II

 

Voting is open until noon November 4th

Edited by rebellious_L

Join or sign in to the forums to disable this ad!

Posted (edited)

Ha, the reason I signed up onto these boards were solely because of these competitions.

 

1) Tripoli

2) Look Happy, It's the End of the World

3) Weapon

4) Born Losers

5) The War is Over

6) Girl Wedged Under the Front of a Firebird

7) Jenni's Song

8) My Out of Style is Coming Back

9) Flashdance II

Edited by Shortcut To Moncton
Posted

Tripoli

Look Happy, It's the End of the World

Failing the Rorschach Test

Born Losers

The War is Over

I Am Not Safer Than a Bank

Big City Life

My Out of Style is Coming Back

Comfortable Criminals

Posted

1. Tripoli

2. On Nights Like Tonight

3. Failing The Rorschach Test

4. Raygun

5. The War Is Over

6. I Am Not Safer Than A Bank (both these "songs" are terrible)

7. Jenni's Song

8. My Out Of Style Is Coming Back

9. Flashdance II

Posted

Tripoli (rooms)

On Nights Like Tonight

Failing the Rorschach Test

Born Losers

Hopeless

I Am Not Safer Than a Bank

Big City Life

My Out of Style is Coming Back

Comfortable Criminals

Posted

1) Tripoli

2) Look Happy It's The End Of The World

3) Weapon

4) Born Losers

5) Hopeless

6) I Am Not Safer Than A Bank

7) Big City Life

8) My Out Of Style Is Coming Back

9) Flashdance II

Posted

1. (Rooms)

2. On Nights Like Tonight

3. Weapon

4. Raygun

5. Hopeless (This one was incredibly hard for me)

6. Bank

7. Big City Life (not that fond of either)

8. Metal Airplanes

9. Flashdance II

Posted

1. Rooms

2. On Nights Like Tonight

3. Weapon

4. Born Losers

5. The War is Over

6. Firebird

7. Jenni's Song

8. Out of Style

9. Flashdance II

Posted

1)Tripoli (rooms)

 

2) On Nights Like Tonight

 

3)Failing the Rorschach Test

 

4) Born Losers

 

5)The War is Over

 

6) Girl Wedged Under the Front of a Firebird

 

7) Big City Life

 

8) Metal Airplanes

-

9)Flashdance II

Posted (edited)

Tripoli

On Nights Like Tonight

Failing the Rorschach Test

Born Losers

The War is Over

I Am Not Safer Than a Bank

Jenni's Song

My Out of Style is Coming Back

Flashdance II

Edited by Manchalivin
Posted

1. Tripoli (Rooms)

2. On Nights Like Tonight

3. Weapon

4. Born Losers

5. The War is Over

6. I am Not Safer Than a Bank

7. Big City Life

8. Metal Airplanes

9. Flashdance II

Posted

1) Tripoli

2) On Nights Like Tonight

3) Weapon

4) Born Losers

5) The War is Over

6) I Am Not Safer Than A Bank

7) Jenni's Song

8) Metal Airplanes

9) Flashdance II

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.