Cake Vs Pie

[Moonlight_Graham]

CAKE OR PIE????

[Crusader]

this was actually really difficult for me to answer... but cake

[Shiri]

I'm going with pie.

[bishopx]

I love both, I make both....but cake wins because of my great-grandmother's homemade chocolate cake, with hershey's frosting, it's my favorite...I made it for the girl for her birthday, right after we started dating...now I get asked to make them for everyone.

[spring90]

I voted for pie... Because banana cream pies own my soul.

 

I'm not much of a cake person though (Only if it's made out of ice cream)

[Some Random]

cake. cheesecake is cake, and there is no pie known to man better than cake of the cheese variety.

[heyrabbit]

I'm really offended that ice-cream is not included...

 

 

that said, I'm a cake eater. it's too easy to fuck up a pie, but cake and frosting is almost always good

 

also i agree with come random's estimate of cheese cake

Edited September 16, 2007 by heyrabbit

[soundless_space]

Cake.

 

Cakes are more fun to decorate. They allow me to have a job.

(Also, good call on the cheesecake dudes!)

 

EDIT Then again a good pie is like one of the best things in the world. Flaky crust, amazing filling... meh I don't know.

Edited September 16, 2007 by soundless_space

[bishopx]

I am going to assembly line, 26 apple pies next weekend. Sometimes it's good to let them eat pie.

[spring90]

cake. cheesecake is cake, and there is no pie known to man better than cake of the cheese variety.

Unless if it's made by someone who is on a sugar free diet, who doesn't notify you of this until everyone has sat down with a big slice of it.

 

True story.

[Hyphnip]

I'm going with pie.

is anyone surprised that Shiri chose pie?

 

anyway, I went with cake because, as good as pies are, they are stuck being small round things, cakes can be anything!

you're never see a pie that is this cool:

http://farm1.static.flickr.com/98/247226924_3c3fbc1608.jpg

[Lauren]

i have to be in the mood for pie, whereas i can eat cake almost whenever i want. so i'm going with cake.

[garsk]

i honestly don't know, but i know ice cream does go well with both.

[Ravenous megin-sane]

i don't like cake at all, so naturally i picked pie

[Prometheon]

Coconut cream pie is friggin amazing, but doesn't really have a crust and thus I dunno if it fits into the standard definition of "pie." Furthermore, key lime pie is one of my all time favourite desserts, but despite this, I still picked cake, because cake is consistantly delicious and amazing, whereas there's lots of gross and sub-par pies.

[Shiri]

is anyone surprised that Shiri chose pie?

I was waiting for someone to say that. Haha. Should have known it would be you!

[Seanathon]

I almost voted cake only on the basis of cheesecake (despite it having a crust), but I went with pie. Coconut cream, apple, and most importantly, pecan.

[Hyphnip]

I was waiting for someone to say that. Haha. Should have known it would be you!

you should have known... but I still love ya.

besides, for all I knew, maybe pie wasn't a slang term for vagina in Israel and you wouldn't have understood anyway.

[hum-an-ole]

I chose pie because it is rare for me to not enjoy it, yet cake often disappoints me by being either too sugary, or too dry. Coconut cream, pumpkin, strawberry-rhubarb, lemon meringue, blueberry

[supercanuk]

Hardest choice ever. I went with Cake.... pie will never forgive me.

[Sparq]

No cake for the impurator.

[Doormat]

Cake is more special occasion, "I really can't deal with all this cream/frosting, but once, twice, three times, is Okay," kind of thing.

 

Pie, on the other hand, can be for breakfast, projects, dinner, makeup...The list is endless.

 

I really can't deal with all the heaviness of cake.

[bishopx]

I do believe Doormat you are on to something. PIE Is like the color black it goes with everything

[Moonlight_Graham]

Wow!!! Cake & Pie in a dead heat!!

 

I much prefer pie. You can't beat a good apple pie, or a strawberry & rubarb pie from the Loblaws bakery ;)

[Azalroth]

Shiri: if Hynip didn't make the comment I'm sure someone would have.

 

Sparq: Well done, a perfect time for that line.

 

And Cake...mmm Cake. I tipped the scales on that one.