this is ridiculous...
1) found a formula that works? this new stuff is completely different from hospital music and as well anything hes done before, it's very experimental. Isn't that what part of this discussion is about? How he's parted too much from his old stuff, then you turn around and say that it's the same...
2) EMO? what the hell is that? of course this stuff (yes, even his new stuff, is far from emo. If you think emo is just like, writing about something sad, then that's just stupid. Emo is a genre for a reason. It's whining dumb lyrics that do not get backed up by what the band is playing (they like playing faster semi-poppy shit) while the singer just whines about shit with no agression or emotion backing it up, just so they can fall into the stupid ass trend. Matthew Good is not emo...far from it, just cause he writes a few songs about his divorce.
3) yes, he's experimenting, these are demos....
4) this conversation has become just stupid, state your opinion on the song and don't bash other people for liking it and wanting to enjoy it, if you don't like it then deal with it.